The Great Cutting Debate: Fabric Shears vs. Rotary Cutters

In our current social media landscape, rotary cutters have become the trendy tool showcased in countless sewing videos. But are they really the magic solution they appear to be? Today, I'm breaking down the real pros and cons of both cutting methods to help you make mindful choices about your sewing tools.

Fabric Shears: The Reliable Classic

Pros:

• Greater Control: The design of traditional fabric shears allows for precise movements around curves and corners

• Ergonomic Comfort: Quality shears are designed to fit comfortably in your hand for extended cutting sessions

• No Additional Tools Required: Unlike rotary cutters, you don't need a special cutting mat or ruler

• Longevity: A good pair of fabric shears can last decades with proper care

• Versatility: Can cut through multiple layers of fabric with ease

• Precision: Allows you to see exactly where you're cutting as you go

Cons:

• Time-Consuming: Can be slower for cutting straight lines and large pattern pieces

• Hand Fatigue: Opening and closing the blades repeatedly can cause hand strain during long cutting sessions

• Learning Curve: Proper technique takes practice to avoid lifting fabric while cutting

  

  Rotary Cutters: The Modern Alternative

  Pros:

  • Speed: Excellent for quickly cutting straight lines and large pieces

  • Smooth Edges: Creates clean, precise cuts on straight lines

  • Stability: When used with weights, prevents fabric shifting during cutting

  • Multiple Layers: Can cut through thin materials efficiently

  Cons:

  • Required Pressure: Demands significant downward force which can cause hand and wrist strain

  • Additional Tools: Requires investment in cutting mats and rulers

  • Safety Concerns: Extremely sharp blades require careful handling and storage

  • Less Precision on Curves: More challenging to navigate intricate pattern shapes

  • Not Suitable for Thick Fabrics: Struggles with multiple layers of heavyweight fabrics

  • Deceptive Learning Curve: Despite appearing easy in videos, requires practice to master

My Interfacing Hack: Best of Both Worlds

As demonstrated in my video, here's my quick method for perfect interfacing pieces every time:

1. Cut your fabric pieces first using your preferred method

2. Lay the cut fabric pieces directly on your interfacing

3. Trace around them with a rotary cutter for thin materials like interfacing

4. No measuring or re-tracing patterns needed!

This approach combines the precision of using your original pattern pieces with the speed of a rotary cutter for thin materials.

When to Choose Each Tool

Best for Fabric Shears:

• Detailed pattern pieces with curves and notches

• Thick or multiple layers of fabric

• Precision work where accuracy is paramount

• When you need to see exactly what you're cutting

Best for Rotary Cutters:

• Straight lines and large pieces

• Thin materials like interfacing

• Multiple layers of quilting cotton